| |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
Adnan
|
Aug 3, 2007
|
 |
COMPARISON OF RAJENDRA KUMAR AND SHAH RUKH KHAN
LETS COMPARISON TWO SUPER STARS OF DIFFERENT ERA ,S. IN ACTING POINT OF VIEW RAJENDRA IS FAR BETTER ACTOR THEN SHAH RUKH.HE PROVED THIS IN ARZOO ,SAATHI GEET AND ETC. WHEN YOU COMPARE THESE TWO STARS IN TERMS OF PAPULARITY THEN SHAH RUKH WINS THE RACE. WHEN YOU SEE THE BOXOFFICE RECORD THEN ITS DIFFICULT FOR YOU TO PICK ANY ONE. SHAH RUKH KHAN HAS THREE BLOCKBUSTERS.DDLJ,KARAN ARJUN,KKHH. RAJENDRA KUMAR HAS FOUR BLOCKBASTERS IN HIS CARRIER.MOTHER INDIA ,MERE MEHBOOB,SANGAM,LOVE STORY. SHAH RUKH KHAN HAS THREE SUPER HITS AND RAJINDER HAS TWO SUPER HITS. YOU COULD NOT CAOMPARE THESE TWO STARS IN TERMS OF BOXOFFICE SUCCESS.BECAUSE THEY ARE EQUALLY SUCCESSFULL. YOU COULD COMPARE THEM IN TERMS OF ACTING ABILITY. SHAH RUKH KHAN HAS WON 6 FILMFARE AWARDS.RAJENDRA KUMAR COULD NOT WON ANY FILMFARE AWARD.IT DOES NOT SUGGEST THAT SHAH RUKH IS BETTER ACTOR THEN RAJENDRA KUMAR. BECAUE FILMFARE HAS NOT A CRITERIA FOR AWARDS.THEY GIVE THE AWARDS UNFAIRLY.I HAVE SOME ARGUMENTS OF THERE UNJUSTICE. IN 61 DILIP KUMAR PERFORMED THE ROLE OF HIS CARRIER IN GUNGA JUMNA BUT FILMFARE GIVE AWARD TO RAJ KAPOOR FOR JIS DESH MAIN GANGA BEHTI HAI.IT WAS A GREAT FAULT MADE BY FILMFARE. AGAIN IN 64 THEY GAVE AWARD TO DILIP KUMAR FORFILM LEADER WHICH DO NOT SHOW THE ACTING ABILITY OF DILIP KUMAR.IN THIS YEAR FILMFARE SHOULD GIVE AWARD TO RAJ KAPOR FOT FILM SANGAM. IN 65 FILMFARE MADE ANOTHER BIG FAULT BY GIVING AWARD TO SUNIL DUTT FOR KHANDAN.IN THIS YEAR RAJENDRA PERFORMED THE BEST ROLE OF INDIAN CINEMA ,FILMFARE SHOUL GIVE HIM AWARDFOR CLASSIC ARZOO. THIS LIST IS VERY LONG. BACK ON TOPIC. SHAH RUKH CANNOT DO TRAGEDY COMMAEDY AS WELL AS RAJENDRA COULD DO. RAJENDRA IS MASTER OF TRAGEDY COMMEDY ROMANCE ACTION OFFBEAT AND ALL GENER S. SHAH RUKH KHAN IS A GOOD ACTOR BUT NOT A GREAT ACTOR AT ALL. INDIAN PUBLIC SHOULD HIGHLIGHT RAJENDRA KUMAR MORE THEN SHAH RUKH KHAN AND OTHER ACTORS. HE IS ONLY LEGEND IN BOLLYWOOD. ALL THE READER WILL AGREE WITH ME.
|
 |
Report Abusive post
Reply
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
Dipen
|
Jul 21, 2009
|
 |
Re: COMPARISON OF RAJENDRA KUMAR AND SHAH RUKH KHAN
There is a pungent tang of nostalgia in acclaiming Rajendra Kumar a better actor . Comparison is healthy when it is unbiased, else the critic becomes one-eyed dear. Rajendra Kumar was, undoubtedly, a great actor, branded as "Jubilee Star". As a tragic hero (Dil Ek Mandir, Sangam, for example) he could leave abiding impressions amongst audiences. In "romantic" manifestations, he was, of course, unparellai and unvanquished in his times. "Aarzoo", "Mere Meheboob","Pyar Ka Sagar","Sathi" and a host are there as spacimens of his romantic magnificence. But, with humble regards to this great star, one can, unhesitatingly, put Shah Rukh Khan on a loftier height in terms of versatility. His performances in negative roles in the films like "Anjam","Darr","Bazigar"are not only superb but full of deep-delved psychological complexities. Sharukh, in the teething of his career had the guts to enact the roles of " anti-hero" so much so that no hero including Rajendra Kumar could dare to take up such challenge under the apprehension that this would prove detrimental to their established images. Sharukh, on the other, has been iconoclast or an image-breaker. His bohemianism portrayed in DDLJ made him the apple of the Nation's eye. His flexibility, frolicness, friskiness cannot be found in Rajendra Kumar. With the passage of time, body-acting has replaced facial or physionomical acting . Naturally, the present actors give great importance on the physique, which has become a part of acting, and for this they are to labour a lot . Aamir Khan, for example, gained six-pack abs for the role in "Gajini", so is the case of King Khan for "Om Shanti Om". If the roles demand to become a "Kabir Khan"(Chak de..),or Vicky (Bazigar), or Devdas Mukherjee (Devdas) Sha Rukh Khan has to translate and condition himself accordingly. Keeping apart dancing capability and fighting dynamism, if we strain nerves with portrayals of different characters, Shah Rukh Khan is a few furlongs ahead. From the T.V serial "Fauji"and "Circus" Sharukh travelled through the zig zag paths laying the milestones like "Raju Ban gaya Gentleman","Kabhi Ha Kabhi Na","Darr", "KKKG' to "Swadesh""Chak De..".As for box office both Rajendra Kumar and Shah Rukh experienced spills and thrills. The former had to bear the disasters like "Aaman","Tangewalla""Jhuk Gaya Aasman", the latter like "Duplicate","Asoke", "Kavi Alvida..." Both struggled to achieve their realms. But, the most striking advantage of the second (SRK) is that he could examine the plus-points of the first (RK) to take after them, and the shortcomings or the lacks, not let it happen with him. Rajendra Kumar was unfortunate for not being able to scrutinize Sha Rukh, while the latter has been fortunate to inspect the predecessor.
|
 |
Report Abusive post
Reply
|
|
 |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
Adnan
|
Jul 22, 2009
|
 |
Re: COMPARISON OF RAJENDRA KUMAR AND SHAH RUKH KHAN
DIPEN SAID: The former had to bear the
disasters like "Aaman","Tangewalla""Jhuk GayA Aasman.
YOUR information is false.
AMan released in 1967 and it was "ABOVE AVERAGE " at the Boxoffice...
Tangewala" released in 1972.it was flop .
"Jhuk Gaya Aasman" was released in 1968 and it was "Below Average.
so,none of them was "Disastrous".
you also said that SRK IS MORE VERSITLE.
Rajendra kumar did all kind of Roles.
He did comic roles in films like"Aas ka Pachchi",Do Jasoos".etc....
He did action roles in films like "Gora aur Kala",Aahuti,Mazdoor zinaabaad".etc.....
He did tragic roles in films like "sangam,Dil Ek Munder,Aarzoo.
he did romantic roles in films like "Aye Milan Ki Bela,.
He did period kind of film when he was at the top of his popularity.Suraj was that film.
He did not do any Villanous roles.Because in those times it was not trend.
Dilip Kumar,Manoj Kumar,Guru Dutt, also did not do villanius roles.
Pran & Ajit were their to do such roles.
|
 |
Report Abusive post
Reply
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
| |
 |
Start a discussion |
 |
|
 |
Create a poll |
 |
|
 |
Quick reply
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
| |
|
|
Done! user, We would alert you when Adnan creates any new discussion
|
|
|
|
|
|
|