Movies Home Showtimes New Releases Top Rated Upcoming Rate Movies Review Movies Random Movie
Celebrities Home Random Celebrity
Videos Home Top Favorites Random Video
People Home Random User
News Home Todays News This Weeks News This Months News Random News
Wallpapers Home Actress Actors Movies Top Favorites Random Wallpaper
Fun Stuff Home Play User Quizzes Play Non-stop Quiz Polls Discussions Upload Photo Upload Video Create Poll Create Quiz Take MTM
Search
Now get Chakpak on your mobile at m.chakpak.com
 
Chakpak.com discussions
Start a discussion
Create a poll
Quick reply
Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
Aumaparna Aug 20, 2007
Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

How can one compare 2 diff actors belonging to 2 diff eras !?

nowadays generations change every 5 years - and u ppl compare someone 20 years senior !? The movies of yesteryear was based on the psyche of Indian citizens during that point of time - where heroines were well dressed covered form tip to toe and the vamps were semi nude bitches - having as lil a role as 15 mins in the entire movie...but look at the scenario now - the heroine is dressed as a crassy yesteryear vamp and is present all the 3 hours of the movie appearing as a crassy female ! - see the pysche has changed tremendously !!

compare Vinod khanna or Rajesh or Jeetendra with Amitabh

compare Salman, Aamir with SRK

with era changes the technology and multimedia effects - how can two diff eras be compared !?

were the Mugals better or the Britishers ...in kicking the servant Indians on their buts ? huh?!

Report Abusive post   Reply
Deepak Aug 20, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
well said
Report Abusive post   Reply
Nisha tiwari Aug 21, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
i agree with u
Report Abusive post   Reply
Adnan Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

dear i  am not agree with you.

we can compare actors of two different generations.

i tell u a criteria.

in my point of view ability of an actor is more important than  technalogy.

you could compare actors of different generations with their ability.

technalogy do not make star's.in modern age,amitabh is performing very well.he was also successfull in the past.

technalogy is not so important for him.he is professional.

his craze towards acting is superb.you could compare shah rukh's attitude,professionalism with dilip or amitabh.

Report Abusive post   Reply
Birju Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

Now U'd see the clash of the titans..ohhh  ... i m waiting..

Report Abusive post   Reply
Aumaparna Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

Birju..a.k.a Prem chopra - u r really naughty !!

Adnan - i understand what u r trying to say. But still i think - this is no justice done to the aged generation - to the yesteryears - to our ancestors as well !

 u c all of us act - more or less - don't we? - we do - it is required both in professional and personal life - now look at the bollywood - acting is inthier blood - it is their bread and butter.

today's actors have learnt from the past mistakes of the aged actors - they have had the chance to study the goofs as well as the goods done previously - which makes them more prudent , appearing more intelligent - thus winning more admiration .....Innocent

kuch samjhe?

if u r intelligent - u will behave like a param hansa (the royal swan) take in the good and reject the bad ....thus the new age (intelligent) actors will certainly appear to be more professional in every respect - they have afterall imbibed the best of so many of them seen in the yesteryears.....Laughing

Report Abusive post   Reply
Shantanu Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
so the clash of Titans has begun!
Report Abusive post   Reply
Adnan Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

....thus the new age (intelligent) actors will certainly appear to be more professional in every respect .at this point i am not agree with u.you rightly say that young actors could learn from the mistakes of old actors.

but,u should understand that all of the students are not good observers in a classroom.some are good and some are bad.

some actors could learn well.but ,it does not mean that they are better than their teachers.in my opinion the teachers always remain teachers.

you could compare ammir with dilip kumar.check,who performed the role of a lover or tragedian best than the other.ammir could learn from the mistakes of dilip. but,dilip could not learn the mistakes of ammir khan.so,if dilip becomes number one.it would be a grand acievement.if ammir khan becomes number one,it would be not a grand achievement in my opinoin.

all the old actors were not great and good.some of them were  not good actors.so, you could compare all the actors with their behaviour,attitude and ability..

Report Abusive post   Reply
Rohana Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
I don't think people should compare the two. They are both good on a different level
Report Abusive post   Reply
Aumaparna Aug 22, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

yeah!even i agree with Rohana - we cannot compare...

its like who was a better warrior Shri Rama or Shri Krishna

the former trained a group of monkeys and defeated multidimensional ravana...whereas Lord Krishna himself did not touch any weapon but annihilated several kingdoms of the size of Ravana's kingdom.....depends on the yuga - the era yaar - during Rama's time there were not many demons - only Ravana was there - a threat to 'society building' in a decent & gracious manner - so Lord Rama finished...but during Shri Krishna time - there were many egoisitc blokes who had to be ended - so....so? no comparision between Amitabh and shah rukh......Arjuna cud be compared with Duruyodhana ...not Bhisma.....generations cannot be compared - don't relive history - don't let history repeat itself - just learn from it ...and proceed....

Report Abusive post   Reply
Vivek Aug 23, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

Hey please do not take us to  Sat Yug,  Treta Yug , Dwapar Yug. I seriously cannot understand the analogies of Mahabharat and Ramayan with respect to our own Kalyug's Bollywood. 
And about the comparison between Heros of yesteryears and  heros of these  days. I would say since the defination of a hero in bollywood has not changed we can still compare them.  Heroes back then and even today:

1. Fall in love.

2. Fight with bad guys.

3. give some extreamely emotional scenes.

4. Crack some PJ's and expect ppl to laugh 

5. Sing a lot of songs 

So why not compare them on which one falls in love better then the other..  

Report Abusive post   Reply
Adnan Aug 23, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

well done,very well said ,vivek,

dear, aumaparna,i could not understand what are you trying to say.

i did not know the history of mahabarat or hinduism,beacause i am a muslim.

Report Abusive post   Reply
Aumaparna Aug 23, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

hmmm...yeah ! i see the point now - u r correct Vivek - i shud not be comparing the Maha yugas and the Incarnations with the Bollywood Drain worms - irresponsible wasteful shameless blokes - all of them!

infact I think they do deserve to be humiliated till their 'death' for what they have done to our Country - how they have misused power and brought India down to the level of street mongrels - showing all contradictary things/falsehood and just making money while the sun shines  !!Money mouth...they have done more harm than good to Indian culture and heritage !

Okie Adnan - worry not - i'll not compare them with yugas of Indian Mythology....but compare them with what they deserve to be compared with ......nincompoops, billions of blue blistering barnacles .... sea urchins lol !Wink

Report Abusive post   Reply
Vivek Aug 24, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

I cannot agree more with you Amuaparna.

But the fact will still remain we Indians love bollywood.

Report Abusive post   Reply
Birju Aug 25, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
Movies Masti Magic as it spells
Report Abusive post   Reply
Aumaparna Aug 25, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

Oh yes! oh yes ! same here dude!!

We, the people love Bollywood - they are the ones who take out our 'Mann ki badhaas'Foot in mouth by hitting some corrupt thug left,right and centerYell...things which we wudn't dare to do in real life.....

Report Abusive post   Reply
Sumitra Dec 20, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

King Shahrukh Khan is the best in Bollywood.

Report Abusive post   Reply
Peace out! Dec 20, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?
SRK ALL THE WAY!
Report Abusive post   Reply
Binita Dec 20, 2007
Re: Ridiculous Comparision ! Amitabh and Shah Rukh!?

It is NOT  ridiculous. Shahrukh Khan is the best.

King khan, he is the best. Superb.

Report Abusive post   Reply
 
Start a discussion
Create a poll
Quick reply