Movies Home Showtimes New Releases Top Rated Upcoming Rate Movies Review Movies Random Movie
Celebrities Home Random Celebrity
Videos Home Top Favorites Random Video
People Home Random User
News Home Todays News This Weeks News This Months News Random News
Wallpapers Home Actress Actors Movies Top Favorites Random Wallpaper
Fun Stuff Home Play User Quizzes Play Non-stop Quiz Polls Discussions Upload Photo Upload Video Create Poll Create Quiz Take MTM
People Home | Random User
Search
Dinrat's Profile
Scrap the user
Ignore the user
Compare MTM
81 Friends
40 Scraps
4753 Recommendations
93 Movie Reviews
357 Discussions
3 Favorite Movies
0 Favorite Videos
6 Favorite Photos
0 Videos uploaded
6 Photos uploaded
Compliments
       
(4)   (0)   (9)   (1)  
     
(1)   (0)   (3)  

Dinrat's Reviews

good performances but characters are flawed...
Feb 19, 2007
 
Movie: Eklavya Compliment the user
Overall Rating

i think this movie fell below my expectations, somehow i find the characters flawed, here is my take...

@eklavya - amitabh

he is considered to be a legendary guard with his 9 generations serving the royal family... he is supposed to do his duty when he helps the royal family get the prince (get the rani pregnant) but somehow he ends up falling in love with her... what was the deal about keeping scarf of rani... all the movie he is speaking about the "doing his dharma/ karma" but i dont see his actions consistent with what he says... besides may be he was a legendary guard (the movie does not give much details) but now at the age of 54 he cannot pretty much see anything, he was bound to fail in his duties (or doing his dharma)... when he failed to guard the king he weeps with guilt of not being able to perform his duties but what was the deal about burning the scarf of rani... that meant as if the rani caused him to fail in his duties which did not seem obvious... perhaps another angle to such actions is that he wanted to destroy the memories of rani, but why?... he has fatherly affection for saif but again in doing so he was failing in his duties...

@rani - sharmila

though it is shown that boman is not the biological father of saif but it is never clear that he was a bad parenting father... still sharmila polarizes saif like anything to save amitabh... was it a silent love story between sharmila and amitabh?...

@prince harshwardhan - saif

again counterpart of what sharmila tells her, he is all up against boman to save amitabh... to the extent that he gets boman killed... it is not clear at all that boman was a bad parenting father... he chooses to play the prince or the son of amitabh as it suits him...

@panna laal chauhaar - sanjay dutt

his role was too small, he is pretty much wasted...

@jyotiwardhan and udayvardhan - jackie and jimmy

definitely not the strongest characters... perhaps definitely not tea drinkers either :-)...

overall if you look at the movie, at the end it seems that it could have been very well a conspiracy by amitabh and saif to get the kingdom... with saif declaring amitabh as his father and all... amitabh choosed to not follow his dharma or duties as it suited him... the justification is that eklavya learns his lesson (from the incident of giving his thumb to guru dronacharya)... another lesson i take from the movie is that the strongest of characters fail in their duties when their blood comes into picture, perhaps a lesson for mother of boman that kameshti yagna shud have been with someone else...

View 0 Comments
Post a comment
Was this review useful?
Useful  (28)
Funny  (21)
Not Useful   (26)
Report Abuse  
Send this review to a friend
Add this to my favourite